She was 18 years old at the time of auditioning and was from Naples, Florida, U.S.
For the blind auditions she sang a song but none of the coaches turned their chairs around. Due to three of the coaches not filling their teams by the end of the auditions, some contestants were given a second chance, including Casey. For her second audition she sang "Stupid Boy" by Keith Urban. Adam Levine turned his chair around and Casey defaulted to his team.
For the battle rounds Adam chose to team her up with fellow contestant Tim Mahoney and gave them the song "Leather and Lace" by Stevie Nicks and Don Henley. After the performance Adam chose to save Casey and Tim was eliminated from the competition.
For the quarterfinals she chose to sing "Black Horse and the Cherry Tree" by KT Tunstall. She also performed with Adam and the rest of her team to "With a Little Help from My Friends" by The Beatles. Casey was given Adam's Vote and went through to the next round with Javier Colon.
For the semi-finals she chose to sing "I Will Always Love You" by Dolly Parton. She also performed with the rest of the Final 8 contestants to a "Faith/Freedom! '90" medley by George Michael. Javier gained the most votes and advanced to the finals whilst Casey was eliminated.
|Blind Auditions||"Stupid Boy"||Keith Urban|
|Battle Rounds||"Leather and Lace"||Stevie Nicks and Don Henley||Tim Mahoney|
|Quarterfinals||"Black Horse and the Cherry Tree"||KT Tunstall|
|Quarterfinals||"With a Little Help from My Friends"||The Beatles||Team Adam|
|Semi-finals||"I Will Always Love You"||Dolly Parton|
|Semi-finals||"Faith/Freedom! '90" medley||George Michael||The Final 8|